139 Thoughts on “Tell us What you Want

  1. Aaron on July 23, 2008 at 10:43 am said:

    It looks like Ice is going to be the big winner, unsurprisingly. I can’t wait to see what she’ll be like.

    I voted for the Hound’s Helmet, because I really want to get my hands on that. Also, I was wondering…it may be a long way off yet, so you may not have decided, but, when making the helmet, do you think it’d be of a wearable quality, rather than just for display like the swords? It’d just be great to be wearing the Hound’s helmet when going to Octocon in 2010, where GRRM is a Guest of Honour!

  2. Yes, it’d be wearable. And technically, if you just want it for a costume, all the swords are fine as well. Its when you start attacking people or things with them that you have to worry.

  3. Matthew on July 23, 2008 at 11:54 am said:

    Since you asked… I want a functional, good-steel version of these swords. I’m not afraid of paying $1500+ for a high-quality sword — that means good high-carbon steel that will stand up to actual use, and hold an edge; hilt and pommel not made of cheap composite or plastic but hardwood or preferably metal. I don’t buy fake stainless-steel swords. I’ve had them fly apart in my hands doing simple drills.

    Make swords that are worthy of the realism that GRRM has brought to epic fantasy. Make swords that I won’t be embarassed to hang on my wall. Make decorative versions too, I don’t care.. I just won’t buy them. I’ll buy the real thing and so will others.

  4. We may one day Matthew, but you must realize the casual fan is unlikely to spend $1500 on a sword.

  5. ICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  6. The Dire Oath on July 23, 2008 at 6:42 pm said:

    If Hounds Helm is Created will it be Mountable on the wall?? i plan on having the whole collection that you create so i was curious if all will be mountable for my “A Song of Ice and Fire” room..

  7. It’d include a shelf stand, but not be wall mountable… so you’d need a shelf.

  8. The Dire Oath on July 23, 2008 at 8:56 pm said:

    #1 will needle have a mount.. #2 i agree ice should be made.. but the splendor of dawn is being forgotten.. also i couldn’t think of any helm wise except for gendry’s bull.. maybe roberts helm from the trident if its gonna go as far as dothraki swords you might as well look into the items of old

  9. The Dire Oath on July 23, 2008 at 8:57 pm said:

    small shields from all the houses.. sorry but i’m very pleased with your direwolf sigil and would love to see your greyjoy and lannister

  10. Oh certainly shields, of probably atleast the great houses, we’ll do. The shields and helms will probably be smaller edition sizes, 1000 pcs.

  11. Ricky on July 24, 2008 at 7:42 am said:

    Talking about shields I would love to see Duncan the Tall’s shield. With the tree and the shooting star. I think it would look great.

  12. Scott on July 24, 2008 at 8:58 am said:

    1. ICE
    2. Needle
    3. Oathkeeper & Widows Wail
    4. Blackfyre
    5. House Shields
    6. Miniture metal Replicas of the Famous armors (Knight of Flowers, The Hound, Jaime, etc)Include a mock shield and sword
    7. Dark Sister
    8. Famous Helms
    9. Heartsbane
    10. Lady Forlorn
    11. Red Rain
    12. Nightfall

    That should make for a busy first year. Get to work… ;)

  13. 3. Oathkeeper & Widows Wail
    than Ice

  14. I have to jump in with Matthew here. I too would like fully functional carbon steel blades. I am actually rather disappointed with Longclaw. Etched stainless? This sword screamed to be done in carbon steel. It would have been a crowning piece to any collection. As it stands, I can’t really see spending the price for a decorative-only piece.

    Also, on the same topic, there is absolutely NO need to pay $1,500 for a good combat blade. There is a fairly wide range of GOOD combat blades on the market for under the $300 mark.

    As an aside, I voted Dothraki, as I have a personal love of slicer/choppers. That and the fact that I have to always ask, just how many variations of a longsword can one make before they all start to look the same?

  15. Becky on July 24, 2008 at 9:13 am said:

    Matthew, I have to agree with VS on this one — you and others would definitely buy the more expensive “real” swords, but you’d be outnumbered by the more casual fan who is content with the cheaper versions. I hope that if VS does make the swords that cost in the $1500 range that it’s profitable for them, but right now, I don’t think it’ll be very cost effective.

    That said, add me to the group of people who voted for Ice. I think that Ice needs to be made before Heartsbane and Oathkeeper are made, simply because of the “timeline” in regards to the swords. Am I making any sense? (If not, that’s okay, I’m not surprised.)

    I keep saying it, but thank you Valyrian Steel! I am so looking forward to owning these swords and helms and the like.

  16. Kristof on July 24, 2008 at 9:31 am said:

    Why is Lightbringer not in the list. Or Robert Baratheon’s Hammer? Can you tell i’m a Baratheon fan? :-D

  17. Lightbringer is fake isn’t it? Maybe I’m misremembering but didn’t Stannis confess in AFFC that he uses a different sword for each showing?

    Roberts Hammer is possible though.

  18. ckadava on July 24, 2008 at 10:32 am said:

    Hopefully, ICE.

  19. David on July 24, 2008 at 11:06 am said:

    I’m picturing it right now. All ASOIAF fans close your eyes and picture it with me : A big white wall, on the center of it hangs the great sword Ice, surounded by Oathkeeper on the left and widows wail on the right…huh? awesome right?

  20. Nebojsa on July 24, 2008 at 11:39 am said:

    Well, i think Ice is most popular sword, but Oathkeeper would be both best looking sword, and probably the sword that would bring you many buyers that are not Martin fans.

    Also i see you answered Matthew that you expect a few people to buy 1500+ dollar swords, and i understand that it is highly questionable if you can see the money at the end of that ‘adventure’.

    But i think that you could maybe have 2 versions of Longclaw. Guards that are nikel plated can sometimes look cheap. And there is no way for me to be sure how it really looks until i see the sword myself, in real, and not just on picture. Genuine leather sounds cool, but i am also worried about pommel material. I am surprised that there is no scabbard, and that plaque is not some ‘easy’ wooden material (would look much better, and more expensive).

    If the price would go up, i am still sure that many would still buy it, including those like Matthew and me. It is not all about carbon steel, but the fact that carbon steel swords, often come with other ‘high end’ materials, and those swords look often very very good.

  21. Nathan on July 24, 2008 at 12:01 pm said:

    Heartsbane! TARLYYYYYYYY!

  22. Jason H. on July 24, 2008 at 1:38 pm said:

    I voted for Blackfyre because I love House Targaryen. I think Ice will look cool, but seeing as how it only appears for part of the first novel, I’m not as jazzed on it as other people. Incidentally I completely agree with kristof, I want to see Robert;s hammer. As a weapon collector, I have yet to find a cool warhammer. On a side note, I ordered my copy of Longclaw, can’t wait.

  23. Ron’s got it right – there can be balance between form, function AND price. Tempered HC steel needn’t break anyone’s bank and it would greatly increase the appeal to sword enthusiasts while not detracting from those who simply want a pretty wall-hanger from GRRM’s world. By far my fav character is Arya, and the Braavosi fighting style likewise appeals to me, so I will buy Needle, no matter what kind of steel is used. I’m also likely to pick up one or two other non-sword pieces – but certainly not Longclaw or Ice in 440ss. I just can’t.

  24. I voted for the Hound’s helmet. I think it would be the most visually appealing all by itself.

    I don’t think that there is a bad choice on that list. I too would love to see Robert’s hammer, that would be sweet. Anything from House Targaryen would be AWESOME!!

    Keep up the great work.

  25. I’m surprised that no one has brought up the dragon bone dagger that was sent to kill Bran in the first book. This is the dagger that started the war. Personally, I’d love to add it to my collection and the sooner the better. So, my vote is for the dagger, right after Needle and Ice.

  26. I went for Ice and Dawn. I’d love to see Dawn. Oathkeeper, too.

  27. I’ve been dying to see ICE! The sooner the better. ;)

  28. Nancy on July 24, 2008 at 5:07 pm said:

    I’d also like the house shields. For a sword I’d like Oathkeeper.

  29. Colm M on July 24, 2008 at 8:23 pm said:

    Oh come on i loveIce and allthe others as much as the next guy but the sword i really want to see is Ser Arthur Dayne’s, the Sword of Morning. Any chance?

  30. That is Dawn Colm, it is on the list, and likely will be made (though, maybe not for a year or two – unless it appears in ADWD and gets more popular).

    The question is, how do we make it? The idea I’m toying with right now is titanium, which is a whiter metal, but we’ll see.

  31. Voted for Dawn. Bring on the morning, Arthur!

  32. I’d love to see and own shields of all the great houses.
    Especially a Greyjoy one. I hope these will be made..

  33. Matthew on July 25, 2008 at 12:30 pm said:

    A couple people have misread me to mean that ONLY high-quality and expensive swords should be made. Of course I don’t mean that. If it’s going to hang on the wall and little more, there’s no need to pay for a functional sword. Problem is.. I don’t hang stuff on my wall I can’t use, so if you make only the cheap stuff I won’t get any of it. Lots of other people probably will, so I understand the business case for keeping the price low. That doesn’t mean there isn’t a business case for people who are serious about their swords.

    To someone else: Yes, you can get cheap(er) and functional. I’m talking functional, artistic, handmade, and unique in that price range. Good stuff, not just “good enough”.

  34. i would like to see ice and hound’s helm

  35. John on July 25, 2008 at 5:16 pm said:

    I want to see Widow’s Wail or Oathkeeper.

  36. I have have already pre-ordered Longclaw and would buy as many of the other items in the poll as possible. I am disappointed to see that more people did not vote for Areo Hotah’s Pole Axe (I did. Don’t underestimate the coolness of the Pole Axe! I would also love to see Robert’s War Hammer. I might buy two of those…

  37. I’m just throwing it out there, because I didn’t see it mentioned, but:
    What of Meera Reed’s spear and net combo? I only think of this because I get to masquerade as my own version of her at the local upcoming Ren Faire.

    Hooray for the crannogmen!

  38. Sime on July 26, 2008 at 6:36 am said:

    I’m assuming that Ice or Oathkeeper should be the next sword done, but I would love to see a Dornish spear produced.

    I can’t really afford to buy any of these swords, but if at some time in the future a Dornish spear was produced I think I would have to buy it, whatever the price.

  39. Sime on July 26, 2008 at 7:16 am said:

    After reading over the comments, I think Mel is right in thinking that there should be some dragon bone blades. After all, they seem to be at the heart of the story.

    In my opinion you should create at least one knife, if not more. Dragon bone knives in the books aren’t specific. That is they don’t have a single specific description to follow so you can theoretically make as many different types/styles as you please.

    You can sell them for a fraction of the sword price and help out GRRM fans that don’t have hundreds of dollars to spare.

  40. Sime on July 26, 2008 at 7:21 am said:

    (sorry for the triple post),

    Valyrian, if you are entertaining the idea of creating shields in the house colours perhaps you could create banners in house colours.

    That could be a simple, cheap money earner for you in between sword sales.

  41. Sime on July 26, 2008 at 7:31 am said:

    (sorry for another post)

    Just to clarify in regard to the dragon bone dagger – I think the dagger that was used in the assasinasion attempt on Bran should be created, but I also think that there is a possibility for other random daggers to be created aswell (if it is cost worthy for Valyrian, of course)

  42. Would love to do banners, but our license doesn’t cover that.

  43. Adamuz on July 26, 2008 at 10:32 am said:

    Cool stuff, but i rather have anithing but ice, not that i hate it, it’s just… why do all the swords gotta be Stark’s?? I’d love to got anything else, like a Dornish spear, but Arthur Dayne’s sword would be awesome. Unbowed, unbend, unbroken.

  44. Charles on July 26, 2008 at 3:56 pm said:

    Well I voted for Oathkeeper, Kingslayer’s Blade, Ice and Dawn (I can vote for multiple can’t I?). Can’t wait for any of them. Longclaw looks great, and I’m sure the rest of the line will compare. I’ve been subscribing to Valyrian’s updates since the site first opened over a year ago, eagerly anticipating your work. Just got my paycheck, and will be ordering Longclaw after I post this. I wanted to add a couple things too.

    Once you guys start releasing the blades, do you intend to settle into a faster release schedule? Waiting for only 2 blades a year would be torture. A new blade every quarter would be great. I know it might be tough working on multiple blades at once, but I’m sure the response will be worth it. Maybe release a smaller blade after each greatsword? The assassin’s dragonbone dagger would be great, like others suggested.

    I’ve seen some dealers of limited numbered collectors items allow buyers to place holds on the same number for future items. Would you guys be willing and able to do that? For example, if I happen to order Longclaw #525 could I be entitled to a hold on Needle #525 and so on unless I forfeit that item? I know some collectors like having the same “number” of all the items in a set, and I certainly intend to own all of these blades.

    I realized while looking at the poll that I have no idea how many of these blades are supposed to look. Lady Forlorn, Dark Sister, Heartsbane, Blackfyre, all those ancient House blades are pretty nondescript. Perhaps some basic sketches of all the blades would be helpful to judge exactly which blades we would like? Nothing too ornate or accurate, just a rough idea of how the blades might look to give us better foresight.

    Well, can’t wait to receive Longclaw, and I really look forward to the rest of the series. Keep ‘em comin’!

  45. We’re trying to get the swords out as fast as we can. As soon as GRRM issues an approval for a design, we start working on the next one. The thing is, with his schedule, it is sometimes hard getting the approvals, and with Longclaw in particular there was a lot of delays as it was the first Valyrian steel blade and so we had to work to define how we’d do the sword ripples.

    But in anycase, we’re not purposefully pacing ourselves. It may come to that, if all the business capital is tied up in existing inventory that isn’t selling we’ll have to slow down, but as long as the blades sell well we’ll just keep going as fast as we can get the designs approved.

    Which is also of course why we can’t give you designs of those other swords, there are none, and making them up without getting them approved would be pointless since they wouldn’t be designs we could use.

    Also, as to the # thing, not really something we can do.

  46. Th Bstrd J.S. on July 28, 2008 at 8:25 pm said:

    All I can say is that I’m looking forward to all the blades you at Valyrian can come up with for “The Song of Ice and Fire!”

    It seems like there are a few people out there that have no idea what it cost for you to make a great sword for a resonable price, (And not be a major knife or sword company now-a-days.) What do they want, a fully functual true damascus blade, rare wood and metal hilts and scales? Maybe throw in a real jewel or two here and there? A gold wire wraped around the leather grips? Ha!

    Sure you can get a functual sword with 1055 or 1095 carbon steel, maybe even for under the 300+ mark if you are really lucky (Made in China more then not LOL,) but those blades are just as much crap as any 440a or 420j at those lower prices. After all a “Good” knife will cost you around 200+ and one with the looks of these swords with real steel like VG-10, S30V or ZDP 189 (just to say a few of the top steels out there), wow you are talking lots of money guys!

    I’m not trying to be rude but before you start yelling at me or saying i dont know what I’m saying LOL i buy AND sell knives and swords for a living. I sujest you research some before you talk. We arn’t buying any 30 swords for $30 of of some infomercial here! $1500+ would be amazing for some of the swords in a higher quality!

    Thanks again Valyrian Steel! Keep up the good work!

  47. The Dire Oath on July 29, 2008 at 7:37 am said:

    This is rather random but if martin is approving these and they go through is there any idea of (if of course the show goes through) the designs and prototypes you have being used… this would increase the resale value unbelievably

  48. We hope so Dire Oath, but we don’t know at this point.

  49. scott on July 30, 2008 at 10:10 am said:

    please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please

  50. Do you plan to make wearable armor, such as Jaime Lannister’s or Loras Tyrell’s plate?

  51. Highly unlikely. You never know though. If we did it would be extremely limited, like 10 total.

  52. The Dire Oath on August 2, 2008 at 12:13 am said:

    How are sales going on Longclaw? This may be rather personal but i am very concerned with the well being of your company, for it provides me with a rare oppurtunity.. i don’t want to buy half the swords and you guys go bankrupt

  53. I ordered Long Claw, can’t wait for Ice. I noticed people asking about Dawn but I was wondering how About Roberts Hammer?

  54. Jason W on August 21, 2008 at 2:35 pm said:

    I too have been in the loop since this first posted, and can tell you that I am seriously looking forward to receiving my copy of Longclaw. Like several others on this site, I also intend to own one of each piece produced.

    Although high carbon would be splendid, I would have to agree with Becky. Affordable is the way to go…and is definitely in scope for my goal to own one of each of these pieces. Not to mention, I have no intention of throwing my collectors items into battle.

    With that said, Ice has been at the top of my list since the beginning.

    One or two swords a year is fine by me, especially after seeing what you’ve done with Longclaw. You are doing a wonderful job, and at least the wait for the swords isn’t as long as the wait between books.

  55. Hi there,
    WOW, where have I been hiding?
    So great to see that you are making these swords…
    The one I really want is ICE!

    Are you able to reprodiuce the red in the blades suggesting Valerian steel?

    I look forward to these.
    I am a prop collector and swords are a great part of my collection. When I first read “Thrones” I thought how cool it would be to have ICE.

    Anyway…I will be watching this site now eagerly :)


  56. The only ones with red are Oathkeeper and Widow’s Wail, both of which were merely dyed by Tywin Lannister because that is how he rolls.

    And yes, we have various methods of replicated that.

  57. Here’s another vote for Robert’s Hammer. I agree with the call for at least one functional weapon and the war hammer would be perfect. Why? It seems like it would be far, far cheaper to produce a usable war hammer than a sword because the hammer is everything the sword is not (why I love it). All these swords are beautiful, highly decorated showpieces, the hammer is a mean and nasty blunt object, simple and to the point. There’s no such thing as a pretty hammer, in my opinion.

  58. Many posts have talked about replicas, but I have not seen anyone ask for the item that is talked about alot, “the iron throne”. It would be a nice peice to add to a collection.

  59. I second all the votes for Robert’s Warhammer. It would give diversity and something I have rarely seen in quality anywhere else. Not to mention for any Ren Faire lovers a hammer would be something nothing short of awesome to sport. I also would love to see Littlefinger’s dagger. The one that was sent to assassinate Bran. Mainly because one of the biggest plots of intrigue surrounded that dagger and it passed through many hands.

    But my #1 vote goes to a Dornish spear. The Red Viper’s of course. It would be the best in my opinion. Nothing like getting a 7 foot

  60. I think that longclaw was a great choice for a first sword. You guys are doing great and I can’t wait to see what else you can do. I am really waiting to see what your shields will be like. Since I brought those up, what would you make them out of? In the books it talks a little about pine shields and oak ect. Which do you think you would make?

  61. Roberts hammer and ICE!!!! Hammer first for sure make em hold out for ICE 3 verison is alawys best anyways right?

  62. Ice and the aforementioned Helms would all be great, but I would like to see some shields painted with all of the main arms of the seven kingdoms. You could vary them slightly in design and size/shape depending on the coat of arms. I just think it would look awesome mounting a full-size shield baring the three-headed Targaryen dragon, or the grey Stark wolf against a snow white field above my fireplace mantle. And please if you do consider making shields make them full size! So many companies making shield “replicas” are made slightly smaller to save on materials or whatever, and as such look ridiculous in person. Also as a side, if you do make the hound’s helm, perhaps Rhaegar’s and/or Robert’s helms from the battle on the trident as well!


  64. I agree that the dagger intended for Bran’s throat would be awesome. I plan on buying each and every piece made in this line. I first only thought of swords, but now I see helms and shields suggested!! Soooooo excited!!!! I’m going to go clear some wall space now…..

  65. And I’d also like to suggest a replica of Jaime Lannisters’ Golden Hand! With a little wood base to display it, maybe even with a glass dome to keep it dust free! And also a replica of the Kings’ Hand necklace, with the hands all clasping each other! And also a Maesters’ chain, with all the different links of metal!

  66. We don’t have a license to do jewelry, we asked about it, but it has already been granted apparently. Maybe one day we’ll be able to get it.

  67. Oh well, at least you tried. Once again thank you for the items you are producing, I’m sure it might get irritating to have all of us demanding more than you can realistically do. But on the other hand I hope there are enough of us demanding, that way you all are inclined to make more:)

  68. Hi all,

    I have to agree with Matt and others – real steel, that will hold a real edge, may not sell in great numbers, but enough to turn a profit. Figure out how much it will cost you to make “high-end” versions of some of the swords, tack on markup to net 20% per, and make 100 of them – particularly the smaller ones, which will keep your costs (and the price) somewhat lower. Really, not much call for a $3000 broadsword in this economy, but “real” versions of Littlefinger’s dagger? You betcha.
    (I’m very glad Needle is coming out in real steel, and I’m seconding the motion for Robert’s Hammer!)

  69. Im suprised more people arnt going for Heartsbane! I know ice is a big 2h too, but we already have 2 stark swords!
    Another vote for roberts warhammer too, would be really cool.
    Also i have to agree with the people saying a more expensive high end quality longclaw would be amazing!
    Thanks Valarian for making these swords!

  70. WWWard on October 31, 2010 at 3:40 pm said:

    I like is the idea of purchasing another blade, but can not considering my current copy of needle is showing pitting from the casting process. There is a crack 2-3mm long on the back of the blade and 2 black pits about 1-2mm across. The house is climate controlled. The warmest it gets is 75 and the coolest is 63. Love the design not liking the quality. Will have to reconsider purchacing ‘ICE’

  71. What about the coin Valar Morghulis just a thought.

  72. I think that the coin would add to any one’s collection. I know it would be a must have for my self and even some other friends/ Fans.

    It would go great with Needle on a plaque, mabe with the translation “All Man Must Die.”

    I also think King Roberts hammer would be Great.

  73. King Robert’s Hammer is already scheduled, for after Ice. Concept art is done and it is being prototyped now.

    We’d like to do coins, and have broached the subject with GRRM before, specifically a Valar Morghulis pendant, but he has previously granted another company the right to make coins and jewelry. This company has not actually been in business, to my knowledge, for a few years, but AFAIK they still legally hold the license.

  74. I spoke too soon, it appears as if after being offline for a long long time, their website is back up.


    So maybe they are still in business.

  75. Well Thanks for the fast response to my post. Its too bad you guys cant do the Valar Morghulis Coin. But maybe things will change in your favor. thank you for the link.

  76. And on Christmas too.

  77. Raquel on June 27, 2011 at 10:59 pm said:

    my votes:

    1st – Arya’s coin (Valar Morghulis i think its called),i think it would be a easy one to do.

    2nd – coat of arms of targaryen, stark, lannister, baratheon, tyrell and tully would be AWESOME!

    3rd – Jaime’s and then Brienne’s oathkeeper

    4th- the dagger they tried to kill Bran

  78. I would like this site to produce and replica of Aero Hotah’s long axe.

  79. MikeyB on October 20, 2011 at 8:46 am said:

    I think Oathkeeper and Widow’s Wail would be nice additions… more so Oathkeeper. Stannis’s sword Lightbringer, the Valyrian dagger used to try and kill Bran, or Dawn from House Dayne would be exciting to see as well.

  80. Hey valyrian steel. I’d like to start off by saying that I’m a huge fan of what you guys are doing and everything is looking pretty good so far. That being said, I do have some constructive criticism and also some suggestions about work I’d like to see in the future. Needle looks great and on Ice the only thing I would say is that it might look better with a longer cross guard. With Longclaw, I understand that it would difficult to produce a pommel as described in the book, but the hilt and the pommel that you are currently making for the sword are a bit lackluster and I think you should carry on but maybe offer a more expensive version with more detail. I think the same is true if you wanted to make the valyrian steel and dragon bone dagger (which would be awesome!). You could offer a more expensive, more detailed version along with one with a simple plastic handle. I have also seen the pictures for the upcoming war hammer of Robert Baratheon, which looks great but for a few things. I think that the hammer head is just a bit to big and heavy looking and the back spike doesn’t look like a very effective Targaryen killer. Other than that it looks great.. For some future projects i would suggest Dawn, Blackfyre, Oathkeeper, the two handed great sword of The Mountain that Rides, Drogo’s arakh, Gendry’s helm, the Hound’s helm, Renly’s antlered helm, and Rhaegar’s ruby encrusted breastplate. Also maybe shields and armor for all the great houses, which if you chose to do please make them life sized and wearable! It’s a bummer about the coins and the jewelry, i would have loved to see maybe the hands’ chain or Robb’s crown but no biggie. One more suggestion would be the sword Ser Vardis uses against Bronn. It has a falcon’s head pommel and a falcon wing cross guard. This could be made to be very aesthetically pleasing and is also a one-handed sword (because Ser Vardis uses a shield) which would be nice. Sorry for writing so much, and I’m just an enthusiast giving input so feel free to take it or leave it. Keep up the good work!

  81. Droghos arakh
    Jogos whip
    House Stark shield
    Valyrian steel dagger used in an attempt to kill Bran
    Tyrions battle axe

  82. Francisco on November 19, 2011 at 1:06 am said:

    I would to see if possible
    Droghos arakh
    Gendry’s Bull Helmet
    Robert’s Stag Helmet

  83. I wish you guys wouldn’t make so few of each sword!

  84. Although obscure the valarian axe mentioned would be sweet inparticular frankish and bearded are both fierce and beautiful to look at styles. Also the helm of the hound to echo everyone else. And yes should be of a usable quality one day we may need them to fight the zombie hoards !!!

  85. Dylan on April 13, 2012 at 4:12 pm said:

    Please make a Blackfyre Replica. Ive been searching all over the internet and not a single blade store has one for sale. I Need This Piece for my collection… Please please please make one

  86. harry on May 2, 2012 at 4:31 pm said:

    why dont you make the valyrian steel arakh that the sellsword caggo wields. i think that this would be a great piece and would match the other blades nicely.

  87. Luvidicus on June 3, 2012 at 9:53 pm said:

    I should like to see a make of Jaime Lannister’s sword. I bet that one would go over very well, and not a flimsy one either. Use the carbon steel, the wood, the strong stuff that will keep an edge and withstand use.

    I would pay for that easy.

  88. I would love to see the fabled valyrian axe created. It would be nice to see something new.

  89. 1.) One final special edition release of Ice.
    2.) Valyrian Dagger used in an attempt to kill Bran
    3.) Night Walker Sword
    4.) Oathkeeper

  90. Any plans for a battle axe? I’ve read the books, and can’t remember offhand if there were any axes used by the main characters.

  91. I just want to now that you guys from Valyriansteel will make the better looking sword “Blackfyre”.
    Just a sugestion if you guys make this sword do something like this one >>>>> http://awoiaf.westeros.org/images/7/73/AEGON_I.jpg
    this images should be enought to do the sword.
    It will be the most beautiful sword in the world.

  92. Larry B on April 27, 2013 at 8:46 pm said:

    Since the 3rd season is already out, Would you consider making Jaime’s Golden hand? It would fall under your licence to make because technically it would be a gauntlet which is a piece of armor. Since you’ve already considered Making Jaime’s golden sword, Getting them both as a matching set would be too good a deal for any self respecting Lannister to pass up.

  93. Depending on how it looks, and if HBO agrees with the interpretation that it is armor, we would consider it.

  94. Beron on July 11, 2013 at 1:04 pm said:

    Euron Greyjoy’s Dragonhorn!!! I’m also partial to the arakh, specifically, the one Rakharo showed Ser Jorah in season 1 episode 3.

  95. When is oathkeeper coming out???? approx??

  96. Jonathan Campbell on January 25, 2014 at 12:26 pm said:

    Recommended productions:
    1) Oathkeeper
    2) Tyrion’s axe
    3) Khal Drogo’s or Caggo’s arakh
    4) Red Viper’s spear
    5) Lightbringer
    6) Barristan’s long sword

  97. carrie on February 8, 2014 at 6:15 am said:

    I have a query are you thinking of doing Rob Starks crown, King of the North.

  98. Lorenzo on May 14, 2014 at 7:48 pm said:

    Damn! No posts since February 8th!
    Ok, my turn.
    Everybody likes bastards villains, they are essential for the stories shifts, even if they do it by dieing. So, If you decide to make “Widow’s Wail” in the future, why not doing “Lion’s Tooth” and “Heartater” too? And so completing a full set of Joffrey Baratheon’s swords?
    That’s something I’d like to have at home.

  99. Braden on August 7, 2014 at 5:56 pm said:

    Hey Guys you should see about making a Renly Baratheon Sword as seen in ether episode 3 or 4 of season two you only see it the scabbard but it still looked awesome.

  100. Would like to see
    rob Starks crown
    Rob stark armour

  101. Broken Wolf on February 11, 2015 at 2:08 am said:

    Dark Sister
    Book Ice
    Aegon Targaryen’s crown
    Crown of Winter

  102. Broken Wolf on March 28, 2015 at 12:51 am said:

    I’d also like to see the chain of the Maesters as well at some point. Although I imagine it’s gonna be a problem getting all those different metals together.

  103. I would absolutely love to see Blackfyre next! House Targaryen needs some love from Valerian Steel! The sword would look amazing next to Robert’s Warhammer!

  104. John G. on April 20, 2015 at 8:59 pm said:

    After seeing Areo Hotah’s “Long Axe” live, it’s hard to argue against it.

    Sure, it’s more of a glaive, but it’s intimidating and the Dornish details look beautiful. I’d be first in line to get one!

  105. Dax Narain on May 18, 2015 at 10:30 am said:

    Would you be able to do a scabbard fro Catspaw please?

  106. Josh2950 on May 30, 2015 at 11:37 am said:

    I think oberyns spear would be pretty cool. Also;
    Blackfyre (that would be the coolest by far and you could go crazy with the designs because I don’t think much detail is given on its description in the books)
    The sword of the morning
    Dark sister
    Needle (show)
    Widows wail
    A kingsguard helm
    Joffreys Crossbow
    Heartsbane (I think that’s the name of the Tarly sword)
    Book oathkeeper
    Meeras trident (three pronged Spear so I’m guessing that’s what it is)
    Danys whip from astapor (or the one from the pit of Daznak)
    Danys dragon eggs from the books
    Maybe something to do with the faceless men (really running out of ideas here)
    Areo hotahs axe
    Some of the sandsnakes weapons
    Something to do with the greyjoys (shield, sword, etc.)
    A masters chain
    Something to do with the arryns?

    • Josh2950 on May 30, 2015 at 11:49 am said:

      Almost forgot;
      White walkers/others swords
      The crows eyes dragon horn
      Targarayen crowns
      The iron throne (book and show)
      Robb’s crown
      Need Starks other sword
      Robert Baratheons helm
      Rhaegars helm
      Unsullied weaponry – spear and sword
      Jaime’s new hand
      Something to do with Bronn
      Danys crown (from the books- the one with the three different coloured dragons)
      Another Arakh
      A dothraki whip
      A dragonbone bow?

    • Josh2950 on May 30, 2015 at 1:09 pm said:

      Lightbringer (stannis’ sword)
      Lightbringer (azor ahai’s sword)
      The hand of the king pin
      Stannis’ crown

  107. Broken Wolf on July 11, 2015 at 8:19 pm said:

    Dark Sister
    Book Ice
    Aegon the Conqueror’s crown
    Crown of Winter
    Falcon Crown
    Grey King’s crown
    Maester’s chain
    Chain of the Hand

  108. Dragonknight055 on July 8, 2016 at 3:30 pm said:

    Please make “heartsbane” from season 6. The sword that Sam steals from his dad, we will probably be seeing him use it in the next seasons.

  109. Dragonknight343 on July 8, 2016 at 3:32 pm said:

    Please make “heartsbane” from season 6. The sword that Sam steals from his father, we’ll probaby be seeing Sam using it in the next seasons.

  110. Phoenix on July 22, 2016 at 1:59 am said:

    When it gives a way, then i where happy to see this one:

    – Bring Stannis Sword with Scabbard to.

    It is really beautiful and looks so great.

    Id would be great!!! ;)

    Cheers K

  111. Nicholas J Talley on July 22, 2016 at 3:55 pm said:

    Fully Functional Damscus Longclaw.
    Fully Functional Damscus Lightbringer and Sword of the Morning.

  112. I would like to see that Heartsbane will be made. Together with the sword holder with antlers to give it a great hunting motif. Would love to have it above my fireplace.

  113. Jeff Varone on July 27, 2016 at 8:35 pm said:

    Widows wail
    Ice wolf pelt scabbard

  114. Rodney on July 28, 2016 at 9:07 am said:

    I think that it would be great if you guys made Blackfyre,Brightroar, Heartsbane, and Darksister. I chose these swords because now that we know Jon is half Targaryn and with Danerys on her way to westeros, everything is coming together for these swords to come into play. I can see Jon with Blackfyre, Danerys with dark sister, and Jon giving back long claw to Jeor Mormont and him changing the pommel back to the house of Mormont bear. Killing white walkers in the war to come.

  115. Rob Zaccaria on July 30, 2016 at 11:49 am said:

    Will you guys be making the show version of Dawn anytime soon?

  116. Anthony B on July 30, 2016 at 11:04 pm said:

    Widow’s Wail
    Oberyn’s Spear

  117. Randall Tarly on July 31, 2016 at 11:19 am said:

    Heartsbane Damascus
    Mormont Shield
    Different version of Robert baratheon war hammer

  118. Randall Tarly on July 31, 2016 at 11:21 am said:

    And Robert Barotheon helm

  119. Jeffrey hoard on July 31, 2016 at 5:13 pm said:

    Widows wail
    White walker spear
    Oberyns spear
    Heart eater
    Any white walker weapons

  120. Jeffrey hoard on July 31, 2016 at 5:20 pm said:

    Roberts Warhammer

  121. Phoenix on October 6, 2016 at 11:02 pm said:

    STANNIS STANNIS STANNIS —–> Sword and its no matter witch name this Sword will have, Lightbringer, the False Lightbringer or just Stannis Baratheons Sword, because STANNIS is the RIGHTFUL KING OF WESTEREOS!

    Please Valyrian Steel tell us about it, did we even had have a Chance to see this Beautiful Sword in the next Years or after the Show??

    Regards Phoenix

  122. Clegan Stark on March 11, 2017 at 9:24 am said:

    Plz make hearts bane in my opinion its by far the best looking and id love to get my hands on it

  123. Jon Jones on May 6, 2017 at 2:04 pm said:

    Please make brightroar!

  124. Stuart Harris on May 12, 2017 at 9:36 am said:

    Heartsbane Damascus

  125. Stuart Harris on May 12, 2017 at 9:37 am said:


  126. Roger Mcfreely on June 12, 2017 at 1:31 am said:

    the show version of Dawn the sword of ser Arthur Dayne the sword in the morning

  127. jacob wilton on September 4, 2018 at 6:53 pm said:

    I want to see the valyrian steel sword of house Lannister brightroar

  128. Joel Rizzi on October 1, 2018 at 11:13 am said:

    1) Blackfyre would be so cool!
    2) Jeffrey’s first 2 sword Lions tooth and heart eater
    3) The mountain in season 7 has a cool looking sword don’t know about a name tho.

  129. Don’t know why I didn’t think of this before. But Areo Hotah’s “pole axe” (though technically a halberd, I believe). He may have been a minor character, but his weapon is one of the best-looking weapons I’ve seen from the show IMO.

    I’m also curious if we’ll see Gendry’s warhammer, now that he has one of his own.

  130. Brock Barber on February 21, 2019 at 4:57 pm said:

    Hey, Valyrian Steel! I’m a huge fan and plan on purchasing the newly re-released issues of Robert Baratheon’s warhammer. It looks incredible and I am very excited on that front.

    As it relates to suggestions for possible new items, I would definitely have to say Brightroar (the mysterious greatsword of House Lannister), firstly, and Blackfyre, as well. The design for the former as depicted in GRRM’s “The World of Ice and Fire” is incredibly beautiful — I have spoken to many a friend, some who are not even familiar with the series itself, and they would be willing to buy such a sword from you guys were you to produce them. This is the sword I am describing:


    If you guys were to manufacture this same sword, identically — greatsword size (60 inches or so), lion’s head pommel, elaborate guard, blade style, and all — you would have a MASSIVE seller on your hands! Guaranteed!

    Blackfyre is an obvious one, and I would love to see the antlered greathelm Robert fought on the Trident with — a huge, wearable product with sprawling steel antlers and visor. Look at the one used by Lyonel Baratheon in the graphic novel “The Hedge Knight”, that one provides a perfect format!

    Again, you guys are awesome and thanks for all of the hard work. My choice is definitely Brightroar — check out the picture if this has not already crossed your radar and give it some serious consideration. It may easily end up being your best product yet if you go along with it!



  131. Shane Hoffart on May 1, 2019 at 8:58 pm said:

    Can y’all please do Heartsbane? After what happened in the latest episode of GOT (S8 03) I feel like I owe it to a character to buy one but no one sells them. Would really love to see one of those. And Dawn too.

  132. Ser Arthuor daynes house sword! Like directly from the show GOT please oh please!

  133. David migdal on July 1, 2019 at 1:45 pm said:

    Do you have a replica of Arthur dayne sword dawn?

Leave a Reply to Vlad Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Post Navigation